A Family Matter by Claire Lynch

A Family Matter by Claire Lynch
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

Claire Lynch’s A Family Matter is a quiet, powerful story that unfolds across two timelines—1982 and 2022—and brings them full circle in a way that’s both heartbreaking and deeply satisfying. At its core, this is a story about love, silence, secrets, and how the past continues to echo through the present.

In 1982, Dawn is adjusting to life as a wife and new mother when she meets Hazel. What starts as a friendship quickly becomes something more, and Dawn is swept into a flood of joy and emotional confusion. The connection is undeniable—but it's also the kind of relationship that society, especially at that time, judged harshly. As Dawn grapples with what this means for her identity, her marriage, and her future, we watch a woman trying to balance her truth with her responsibilities.

Fast forward to 2022, and Heron—Dawn’s ex-husband is now in his sixties and facing a terminal diagnosis. He knows he has to tell their daughter Maggie, but there’s more than illness haunting him. He’s been holding onto secrets for decades, truths that could shake Maggie’s understanding of her family—and herself.

This book is deeply character-driven, and Lynch writes with a calm, gentle intensity that sneaks up on you. The pace is slow in places, but it works. You’re invited to sit with the characters, to live in their quiet moments, and to feel the emotional weight of the decisions they’ve made. As the story unfolds, each character gets a moment to breathe and be fully seen. Watching their younger and older selves woven together in a non-linear narrative made it feel even more real.

One of the most moving elements is how Maggie unknowingly mirrors her mother’s emotional journey, forty years apart. Their internal monologues, filled with longing and uncertainty, feel like they’re speaking to each other across time.

Beyond the family drama, this novel highlights an overlooked part of queer history. Lynch gently but clearly explores the stigma lesbian women faced in 1980s Britain under Thatcher’s government—how they were painted as corrupt, unnatural, and the damage those views inflicted on individuals and families.

At just 240 pages, this debut novel carries the emotional depth of a much longer book. It’s tender, thought-provoking, and lingers long after the final page. A Family Matter is a story of what’s said, what’s left unsaid, and the cost of both.










View all my reviews