The Gallagher Place by Julie Doar

The Gallagher Place by Julie Doar
My rating: 4 of 5 stars

The Gallagher Place by Julie Doar is an atmospheric, slow-burning debut that blends family drama, buried secrets, and the lingering echoes of a long-ago disappearance. Set in New York’s Hudson Valley, the novel follows Marlowe Fisher, who returns to her family’s Gray House after twenty years and finds herself confronting the disappearance of her teenage friend Nora and a newly unearthed body on the property.

Doar’s pacing is deliberate and confident, shifting between past and present with just enough tension to keep readers guessing. The Hudson Valley landscape feels alive on the page—the woods, the damp earth, and the aging farmhouses all pulse with an uneasy quiet that borders on Gothic. It’s a story about memory and guilt as much as mystery, and Doar captures the emotional cost of revisiting a past that refuses to stay buried.

Still, some elements falter. A few secondary characters feel thinly drawn, and certain plot turns—particularly those linked to land disputes and local politics—stretch plausibility. Yet even with these flaws, the emotional weight lands. The Gallagher Place succeeds most when it lingers in the quiet spaces—where grief, longing, and truth blur together. A haunting, confident debut that marks Julie Doar as a writer to watch.

View all my reviews

https://www.amazon.com/dp/B0DTP65VNT/?bestFormat=true&k=the%20gallagher%20place%20julie%20doar&ref_=nb_sb_ss_w_scx-ent-pd-bk-d_k0_1_19_de&crid=Y8KJ5NBKZHU2&sprefix=The%20Gallagher%20Place#:~:text=https%3A//amzn.to/3IQ1lck